Credited from: LEMONDE
A federal judge has ruled that Luigi Mangione will not face the death penalty for the murder of UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson. Judge Margaret Garnett dismissed two federal charges, including murder through the use of a firearm, citing legal flaws in the charges, which allowed capital punishment to be considered by jurors. The ruling means Mangione is now only facing federal stalking charges that could lead to life in prison without parole, as well as state-level murder charges with similar potential sentences, according to Al Jazeera and BBC.
The judge's decision effectively shuts down efforts by the federal government, under the Trump administration, to pursue capital punishment in what was termed a "premeditated, cold-blooded assassination." This situation has drawn public interest and criticism regarding the handling of the case. Judge Garnett emphasized that stalking, which formed the basis for establishing a "crime of violence," does not meet this criteria under federal law, a key factor in dismissing the charges that would have allowed a death penalty, as noted in reports from Reuters and NPR.
In a significant related ruling, the judge allowed evidence collected from Mangione's backpack to be presented at trial, including a handgun and a notebook detailing threats against Thompson. This evidence was contested by the defense, which claimed the search was illegal due to lack of a warrant; however, Garnett determined it was a reasonable action based on the circumstances, as highlighted by India Times and South China Morning Post.