Credited from: CBSNEWS
A Utah judge has ruled against a motion to disqualify the prosecutors handling the case against Tyler Robinson, who is accused of killing conservative activist Charlie Kirk on a Utah college campus. The defense argued that the presence of the daughter of a deputy county attorney at the shooting constituted a conflict of interest, which raised concerns about the integrity of the prosecution. District Judge Tony Graf stated that there is "not a significant risk" that Deputy Utah County Attorney Chad Grunander's loyalty to his daughter would compromise his work or interfere with Robinson's rights, according to Reuters, CBS News, and LA Times.
The shooting occurred on September 10 during a campus event at Utah Valley University, where Kirk was addressing an audience of approximately 3,000 people. Robinson, 22, is charged with aggravated murder, and prosecutors plan to seek the death penalty. The defense argued that the quick decision to pursue such a severe penalty was influenced by "strong emotional reactions," which they believed justified the disqualification of the prosecutors. However, Judge Graf noted that the emotional responses from those associated with the case should not prevent prosecutors from performing their duties, as stated in CBS News and LA Times.
Judge Graf's ruling emphasized that the prosecutor's daughter would not serve as a witness in the trial, further mitigating concerns about bias. "Prosecutors need not be immune to the emotional response of others to prosecute a case," he remarked. The defense's concerns about maintaining a fair trial also extend to the handling of media coverage and the potential release of video footage that could impact public perception of the case, according to Reuters and LA Times.
The judge also addressed a request from various news organizations to maintain transparency in the proceedings, which is significant as the trial progresses. Defense attorneys are seeking to exclude cameras from the courtroom, arguing that coverage by certain outlets could impact the trial's integrity. Nonetheless, prosecutors, alongside Kirk's widow, have advocated for open proceedings to ensure public access to the trial, as noted in CBS News and LA Times.