Credited from: LATIMES
A Utah judge on Monday rejected a congressional map proposed by Republican lawmakers, opting instead for an alternative that establishes a Democratic-leaning district. Judge Dianna Gibson stated that the Republican-drawn map "unduly favors Republicans and disfavors Democrats," emphasizing that it did not comply with Utah law against gerrymandering. Her decision favors updated district lines submitted by the League of Women Voters of Utah and Mormon Women for Ethical Government, which revolve around preserving Salt Lake County as a singular district rather than dividing it among four, as was previously done, according to CBS News, The Hill, Reuters, and Los Angeles Times.
The newly approved map enhances the Democratic party's prospects in a state that has not elected a Democrat to Congress since early 2021. Gibson's decision arrived amid national redistricting tensions, particularly after Republican-led states like Texas altered their maps to favor their party. "This is a win for every Utahn," emphasized the state’s Democratic leaders, invoking a commitment to fair representation, according to The Hill and Reuters.
While Democrats celebrate this turn of events, Republican lawmakers have criticized the decision, calling it a "gross abuse of power." They contend that Gibson lacks the legal authority to adopt a map not approved by the Legislature and have initiated a petition to repeal Proposition 4, which established Utah's Independent Redistricting Commission. This situation showcases the broader implications of redistricting battles across the U.S., where both parties are strategizing to influence congressional control ahead of the midterm elections, as detailed in The Hill, Los Angeles Times, and Reuters.