Credited from: BBC
A New York state appeals court has officially overturned a $515 million civil fraud penalty against President Donald Trump, describing the amount as "excessive." This ruling represents a significant legal gain for Trump as he contended with accusations that he inflated his wealth to secure favorable loan terms for the Trump Organization, according to Al Jazeera, Reuters, and South China Morning Post.
The court’s decision, made by a five-judge panel in New York’s Appellate Division, came after nearly 11 months of deliberation, a notably lengthy process for appellate courts, which usually resolve cases in weeks or months, as reported by Los Angeles Times and CBS News. The court stated that while Trump was found liable for fraud, the financial penalty imposed by Judge Arthur Engoron was unconstitutional under the Eighth Amendment.
Initially ordered to pay $355 million plus interest by Engoron, Trump's financial liabilities had grown to approximately $515 million. The appeals court deemed this penalty excessive while allowing for non-pecuniary sanctions against Trump and his sons, restrictions which have been temporarily lifted but could still be enforced, according to Newsweek and HuffPost.
New York Attorney General Letitia James, who initiated the lawsuit, has indicated plans to appeal the appellate court’s decision, emphasizing the court’s affirmation of the fraud findings against Trump and his organization. She stated this ruling reveals that “the president violated the law,” and she aims to escalate the matter to the New York Court of Appeals, as highlighted by Business Insider and NPR.
Trump celebrated the ruling as a "total victory" against what he characterized as a political witch hunt, maintaining that the case and subsequent verdict were targeted attempts to undermine his presidency and business, according to TRT Global and Le Monde.