Key Takeaways:

• The death toll from a standoff between police and illegal miners in South Africa has risen to 87.
• Authorities have faced backlash for using starvation as a tactic to force miners out of Buffelsfontein Gold Mine.
• Over 240 survivors have been rescued, but all have been arrested as they emerge poorly nourished and traumatized.
• Calls for an independent inquiry into police actions are gaining momentum as community anger mounts.

The recent standoff involving police and illegal miners in South Africa has culminated in a tragic outcome, with 87 miners confirmed dead as of Thursday. The situation, which took place at the Buffelsfontein Gold Mine near Stilfontein, has elicited widespread criticism over the methods employed by authorities to deal with the miners trapped underground. Since August 2024, an operation known as "Vala Umgodi," or "Close the Hole," involved cutting off food and water supplies to compel the miners to surface, a tactic referred to as "smoking them out."

Initially, police spokesperson Athlenda Mathe reported that 78 bodies were recovered during a court-ordered rescue operation, with an additional nine bodies retrieved prior to the official operation. This has been described as one of the deadliest incidents of illegal mining in South Africa's recent history, underscoring the dire consequences of the government's harsh approach to illegal mining.

Authorities estimate that approximately 1,500 miners managed to escape through various shafts, but many remained trapped, allegedly due to fears of arrest. Activists have criticized the government for turning a blind eye to the miners' plight, claiming that inadequate response time and refusal to provide necessary supplies led to the disastrous outcome.

Human rights organizations have charged that the police’s tactics resulted in starvation and dehydration among those trapped inside the mine. Community groups began their own rescue attempts when authorities labeled the miners as criminals, refusing to assist them. Local leader Johannes Qankase labeled the situation a “disgrace,” stating, “If the police had acted earlier, we would not be in this situation, with bodies piling up.”

Miners, often referred to as “zama zamas,” are undocumented foreign nationals from neighboring countries such as Mozambique, Zimbabwe, and Lesotho. Their illegal mining activities have become a significant issue for South African authorities, costing the country over $3 billion last year alone due to the illicit trade of gold. Policymakers, citing the need to combat this underground economy, adopted increasingly harsh measures against the miners.

The backlash against police tactics has prompted calls for an independent inquiry into the events leading up to this tragedy. The Democratic Alliance, South Africa's second-largest political party, has urged President Cyril Ramaphosa to investigate the circumstances that allowed this humanitarian crisis to develop.

Meanwhile, as the police's official rescue operation has concluded with over 240 survivors being extracted, questions arise regarding their treatment. All individuals who made it out of the mine are now under police arrest, despite their harrowing experiences. Community volunteers have stepped in under perilous conditions to assist with the rescue, highlighting the urgent need for humanitarian considerations in the approach to illegal mining.

This tragedy not only raises crucial questions about governance and human rights in South Africa but also stresses the necessity for urgent reforms to address the underlying issues of illegal mining and its impact on communities.

For further information, visit the AP News Africa hub.